The Estate of Rodney Coles v City of Richmond

HammondTownsend Wins Workers’ Compensation Benefits for Family of Fallen Richmond Firefighter

Case Result: Full Commission Affirms Award of Death Benefits Pursuant to Virginia Heart/Lung Presumption Laws for First Responders

When a City of Richmond firefighter died suddenly from a fatal cardiac arrhythmia, his family faced the difficult challenge of pursuing the workers’ compensation benefits they deserved. HammondTownsend represented his widow, Amy Coles, and fought to establish that his death was connected to his service as a firefighter.

Despite the insurance carrier’s insistent and repeated denials of the claim, HammondTownsend successfully secured workers’ compensation benefits for Mrs. Coles at both the Deputy Commissioner level and the Full Commission appellate level.

The Challenge: Proving a Firefighter’s Death Was Work-Related

Rodney Coles was a firefighter for the City of Richmond for nearly fifteen years, before he died suddenly on August 3, 2023, from a fatal cardiac arrhythmia. Under Virginia Code § 65.2-402(B), qualifying firefighters who have completed at least five years of service are entitled to a legal presumption that certain heart conditions causing death (or other disability) are occupational diseases suffered in the line of duty.

However, the insurance carrier challenged the claim, arguing that Mr. Coles’ documented pre-existing high blood pressure was the cause of his death. The carrier also argued that the claim was barred by the statute of limitations.

Not only was Mrs. Coles grieving the sudden and tragic loss of her husband of over 22  years, but she faced significant legal challenges as she fought to secure the benefits available to her as the widow and surviving beneficiary under Virginia Workers’ Compensation law.

The HammondTownsend Fight: Establishing the Firefighter Presumption

HammondTownsend fought to prove that Mr. Coles was entitled to the presumption by establishing the connection between his firefighting duties and the fatal heart condition that caused his untimely death.

The case involved a detailed review of medical records, autopsy findings, pre-employment physical testing, and complex medical issues. HammondTownsend relied on the opinion of an expert physician, specialized in occupational medicine,  who explained in detail how the stress and occupational exposures associated with firefighting contributed to Mr. Coles’ cardiac enlargement and ultimately his fatal arrhythmia.

The legal arguments focused on the nuanced intricacies contained in Virginia’s presumption laws for first responders, as well as specific case law associated with these laws.

The Result: Mrs. Coles won. HammondTownsend won.

The Deputy Commissioner ruled in favor of Mrs. Coles on February 19, 2026, finding that the insurance carrier had failed to rebut Virginia’s statutory presumption for first responders. The carrier appealed, asking the Full Commission to reverse the Deputy Commissioner, find for the City of Richmond, and deny the benefits awarded to Mrs. Coles.

On August 24, 2026, the Full Commission, consisting of three Commissioners, affirmed the Deputy Commissioner’s decision. The Full Commission found that the insurance carrier had failed to rebut the presumption that Mr. Coles’ fatal heart condition was a result of his employment as a firefighter for nearly fifteen years. The original award of benefits to his widow, Mrs. Coles, was upheld.

The Outcome: Ongoing Death Benefits for Mrs. Coles

Through HammondTownsend’s representation, Amy Coles was awarded death benefits pursuant to the Virginia Workers’ Compensation Act, following her husband’s death. Under the Award, weekly benefits will continue to be paid to Mrs. Coles until the statutory 500-week benefit period has expired. The Full Commission’s decision affirmed the Award and rejected the insurance carrier’s appeal, providing Mrs. Coles with the benefits she fought to secure in the wake of her husband’s death.

A Message of Gratitude

For HammondTownsend, helping injured workers and families navigate the Virginia Workers’ Compensation system is about more than winning a case. It is about standing up for people during some of the most difficult moments of their lives.

After the successful outcome, Mrs. Coles shared her appreciation for the HammondTownsend team:

“Again, thank you all for everything. What a blessing I found you guys.”

At HammondTownsend, we are honored to stand alongside Virginia workers and their families when they need someone fighting for them in the pursuit of justice.

If you lost a loved one due to a potentially work-related heart condition or occupational disease, our attorneys can help you understand your rights under Virginia Workers’ Compensation law. Contact HammondTownsend for a consultation.

Have you been injured on the job? Call HammondTownsend.

With over 45 years of combined experience handling Workers’ Compensation claims, our attorneys have recovered over $3 Billion for injured workers. As an exclusive injured workers law firm, our team fights for the compensation you deserve!

We are THE Virginia Workers’ Compensation Law Firm. Serving injured workers across the state of Virginia: Northern Virginia, Richmond, Roanoke, Lynchburg, Harrisonburg, Charlottesville, and Hampton Roads.

Contact us for a FREE case evaluation.

Workers’ Compensation Challenges – Eva H.

We know that nurses and other healthcare providers often have accidents that cause them injury in the daily routine of caring for patients of all shapes, sizes, and attitudes. However, […]

Morgan v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.

This case involved multiple injuries to the same body parts over the course of two years. The client injured her low back in 2012 while she was pushing and aligning […]

Escamilla v. Campco, Inc. (2009)

Case Details Claimant, an undocumented worker from Mexico, worked as an unskilled construction laborer.  He fell from a floor joist onto a concrete floor resulting in a traumatic brain injury.  […]

Schedule A Free Case Evaluation

Fill out the form below for a free case evaluation.

Scroll to Top